Uncertain mineral rights

A number of discussions on this site have involved people who were told after they signed a lease that they didn't own the mineral rights. There have also been cases where someone doesn't think they have mineral rights, but the lessee tells them they do own the rights and offers a lease.

I know some leases have a clause requiring the lessor to "defend the title," i.e. pay the lessee's legal expenses in case of disputes.

This sounds really dangerous.

Is it common to sign a lease that says, in essence, "I convey any mineral rights I own for this property. I don't claim to own these rights. I'm not responsible for any damages if it turns out I don't own these rights."

i.e. lessee does the legal stuff regarding mineral ownership and I don't have any responsibility if they get it wrong.

Views: 41

▶ Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by The_Baron on August 18, 2009 at 7:41
The point I was making is that even with the no warranty clause, you might still be on the hook.
Permalink Reply by The_Baron on August 18, 2009 at 7:42
In the above case, there was a no warranty clause, but the lessor still had to return the money.
Permalink Reply by Mac Davis on August 18, 2009 at 11:34
You're probably still in a better position in court.

Wouldn't you agree:

Not having "warranty" clause is better than a warranty clause.
A specific "no warranty" clause is better than simply not having a warranty clause.

Unfortunately, nothing is safe in court these days.

RSS

Support GoHaynesvilleShale.com

Top Content 

1 BPX hits it out of the park with 3 Bossier Parish CULs

BPX hits it out of the park with 3 Bossier Parish CULs
2 "Rebalancing Volumes"

"Rebalancing Volumes"
3 Site Not Loading Fully?

Site Not Loading Fully?
4 Haynesville Fairway could support drilling into the 2050s?

Haynesville Fairway could support drilling into the 2050s?
5 Chevron acquires Smackover Brine Leases in AR and E TX

Chevron acquires Smackover Brine Leases in AR and E TX
6 Mitsubishi Corp in talks to acquire Aethon Energy Management

Mitsubishi Corp in talks to acquire Aethon Energy Management
7 Lithium Brine Lease letter from Red Oak East, LLC - Location Cass County, TX, near Naples, TX

Lithium Brine Lease letter from Red Oak East, LLC - Location Cass County, TX, near Naples, TX

Blog Posts

Tuscaloosa Trend Sits On Top Of Poorest Neighbourhood For Decades - Yet No Royalties Ever Paid To The Community -- Why??

In researching the decades-old Tuscaloosa Trend and the immense wealth it has generated for many, I find it deeply troubling that this resource-rich formation runs directly beneath one of the poorest communities in North Baton Rouge—near Southern University, Louisiana—yet neither the university ( that I am aware of)  nor local residents appear to have received any compensation for the minerals extracted from their land.

This area has suffered immense environmental degradation…

Continue

Posted by Char on May 29, 2025 at 14:42

Not a member? Get our email.

Groups



© 2025   Created by Keith Mauck (Site Publisher).   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service