I've owned minerals in LA and TX since 2008. I've been in the ad business for more than 30 years, working mostly as a graphic designer and ad copywriter.
That said, I created the attached meme that reflects (also vents) my frustrations with operators intentionally keeping me in the dark—a recurring theme on GHS as we all know.
Hope you like it.
Tags:
LOL! Thanks, Jimmy. Humorous but also unfortunately accurate. Once a mineral owner signs a lease and becomes a lessor they are largely ignored. Common courtesy in the majority of cases is a nonstarter. After being ignored over a serious issue, the only course for the mineral owner is an attorney and potentially litigation. The legal response of the industry is deny, delay, deny, delay and try to wait out the mineral owner. It is largely a successful strategy and therefore is used continually across the entire industry. The O&G industry is the most litigious industry around. When they aren't in litigation with mineral owners, they are suing each other.
Thanks for the reply and the sad yet enlightening info. Comstock is the best at responding to emails. Initially. But, by and large, when I ask a follow up question that indicates I might have done some homework, the reply is usually "I've referred this to so and so department, please allow 60 days..."
You're welcome, thanks for posting. 60 days is not customer service. It is a corporate put off. More deny and delay.
Agree!
Apropos, per a recent "development," is there a rule of thumb, requirement, law, etc. about the length of time a Division Order should be sent out after a well starts producing? This is regarding 4 alt unit wells (Comstock) in the Spider Field I've posted about before. All four were turned to sales 6/26/26. I know I'm up against City Hall here, but had to ask.
Why I'm Asking: September 18th, I emailed Comstock asking about Division Order status. Their response: "Check back in 60 days to see if we have an update for you." So, this morning (60 days later) I forwarded the September 18th email asking for an ETA. Their response made me laugh at its stupidity: "The analyst will email you a copy of the division order when it is available."
Jimmy, I'm not surprised. Once a mineral owner signs a lease or is force pooled, the operator holds all the cards. Neither the Department of Conservation and Energy nor the Attorney General will get involved on behalf of Louisiana mineral owners. A division order should be sent to all mineral lessors under a well within 90 days of first production. Comstock and all other Haynesville operators have access to the original division order title reviews and only need to confirm a payment decimal based on the length of perforated lateral in each unit of an HC well.
You said that right! When I first contacted Comstock about these wells, it was in December, right after they had started drilling. I was actually given an estimated completion date of July and told "Division Orders will be mailed out 60 days after. We will be able to answer ownership questions then." Not the first time an operator has lied to me, so not that surprising I guess. So, I'll just be a good little royalty owner and shut up. I don't think they like me. I do my homework and ask too many questions that indicate I'm not exactly clueless.
Otherwise, I guess my only option is to hire an attorney if they go past 180 days or something, huh? Thanks for your response and wisdom!
For what you are asking, no attorney should be required. For mineral owners, this is a voting question. Let me provide an example. The advent of Haynesville Shale horizontal wells was 2008. The state regulation for submitting unit surveys was 90 days post first production. In 2017 I grew tired of the vast number of delinquent unit surveys and spent several days on research to identify the extent of the problem. At that time there were 850 delinquent surveys and the average age delinquent was over six years. I wrote a letter to the Office of Conservation department head, no reply. I wrote to the Commissioner, no reply. I wrote to the Secretary of the Department, no reply. Finally out of frustration, I wrote to the governor's office. I got a reply. Two months later I got a letter from the Commissioner stating that going forward Haynesville operators would be required to submit twelve surveys a quarter, forty-eight annually until all delinquent surveys were submitted. The governor was John Bel Edwards. If I was to go through the same process under this administration, I would expect no reply. Landry is in the pocket of the O&G industry. Your vote matters also for judges. Owing to the Haynesville Shale being the driver of litigation and legislation basically state wide, the judges of the Second Circuit Court of Appeals have made a number of rulings that disadvantage mineral owners. Few of those judges have any background in oil and gas and mineral law. All are heavily supported by big business including the O&G industry. Voters in the districts making up the Second Circuit have had a number of elections to choose someone that has their interests at heart. The public has little interest in those races leaving special interests to influence the elections. If voters are apathetic, special interests will always get their way.
388 members
459 members
240 members
257 members
442 members
© 2026 Created by Keith Mauck (Site Publisher).
Powered by
GoHaynesvilleShale.com is where mineral owners, landowners and oil & gas professionals discuss the Haynesville Shale, Austin Chalk, Terryville Complex, Tuscaloosa Shale, Lower Smackover Brown Dense and lithium plays. Ask questions, share what you know, and keep up with activity in your parish or county. [ Read More ]