Lawsuit Claim: Chesapeake's negligence to blame in well blowout death?

Lawsuit: Chesapeake's negligence to blame in well blowout death

By Vickie Welborn • vwelborn@gannett.com • April 6, 2010


Chesapeake Energy's refusal to take precautions to control the pressure of one of its natural gas wells in Grand Cane led to a blowout in November that killed one man and seriously injured another, the men's relatives claim in a lawsuit filed in a Texas federal court.

 

Killed in the Nov. 18 accident was James Dennis, 58, of Bullard, Texas. Critically injured was co-worker Jimmy Siler, 30, also of Bullard. Both were employed with Dynasty Transportation LLC, of Broussard, which provides truck transportation for the oil and gas industry.

In addition to the death and injury, the blowout sent approximately 15 families away from their homes for two days. Several DeSoto Fire District 8 firefighters were treated and released for respiratory problems after rescuing Dennis and Siler from the well location on George Hunt Road.

Dennis' wife, Barbara Dennis, along with two daughters, Jill and Lauren, and Siler named Chesapeake as the defendant in the personal injury and wrongful death petition filed last month in the Eastern District of Texas. They seek unspecified damages and a jury trial.

"It is not our policy to comment on pending litigation," said J. Kevin McCotter, Chesapeake's senior director of corporate development.

The lawsuit alleges Dennis and Siler were working as crane truck operators at the well site along with contractors Innovative Wellsite Systems Inc. and JetBlast. Innovative employees were directed by Chesapeake to change out the pins on the wellhead.

Dennis and Siler hooked the crane truck to the equipment at the wellhead to allow Innovative workers to change the pins, "when suddenly a violent explosion occurred and the wellhead blew out," the lawsuit states.

Dennis and Siler were in the path of the blowout. Both suffered broken bones and critical injuries. Dennis died at the scene.

"Prior to beginning the work, Innovative employees spoke with the Chesapeake company man on location and requested Chesapeake to 'kill the well' by placing a down hole packer because of the high pressure on the well," according to the lawsuit. "Chesapeake refused to take the time to do so and wanted Innovative to continue the work with the lubricator which was set. A down hole packer would have kept the pressure of the well down hole and away from the wellhead where the work was being performed. Chesapeake's refusal to set the packer allowed the pressure to stay near the wellhead, and thus allowed the wellhead to blow through one of the pins being set by Innovative."

The plaintiffs claim Dennis' death and Siler's injury occurred because Chesapeake did not take steps to control the gas in the well by "holding it down hole."

References also are made in the document to other blowouts at Chesapeake well sites in the Haynesville Shale region, particularly in DeSoto Parish. Four men have died in rig-related accidents since the shale play hit the region two years ago.

 

Buck

Views: 1007

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

That is clearly the job of plaintiff's attorney.
What would you expect from Shreveport Pravda, I will let the courts decide this case, but my thoughts and prayers go out to the family.
CMK - Thanks for the "thoughts & prayers," most compassionate. Sincerely.

Regardless of the slant of the article or bias of the writer, this man was someone's son, husband, father. A life was lost. It's not political as the "bottom line" of a corporate entity, and the development of the play (regardless of economic impact) should not outweigh the value of human life.

Mr. McCotter had the right idea ... no comment. In this instance he's a smart man.
Don't expect any more than one half of the story from this writer.
Oh I know that much
Ms. Welborne does have a habit of not fully researching her stories.
The Shreveport TImes is an absolute joke, my highschool newspaperwas more professional and accurate, I have never seen a more incoherent group of writers in one amalgamation. I have a strong inclination to believe many of them were educated by the blathering propagandist Wiley Hilburn. I can't recall one article concerning the Haynesville Shale that wasn't amateurish at best.
They are transitioning to a small tabloid format in the near future, if they make it that long.
Here's more from the SE Texas Record, which is a legal journal ...

http://www.setexasrecord.com/news/225621-crane-operators-sue-after-...

"The families of the workers claim Chesapeake Energy is liable for the men's injuries for failing to "kill the well." According to the lawsuit, Innovate employees requested that a down hole packer be used to keep the pressure of the well downhole away from the wellhead where the work was being preformed."

80)
The_Baron - I did some research of my own, having been prompted by the news in this article. Would this be a good place, in your opinion, to keep up with the operators & their compliance with EPA regs?

http://www.epa-echo.gov/cgi-bin/get1cReport.cgi?tool=echo&IDNum...

Thanks - 80)
To be fair, Chesapeake is a member of ISN and requires it's subcontractors to subscribe.

http://www.isn.com/news/ISNWelcomes/ChesapeakeEnergyContractorLette...

"We are pleased to announce Chesapeake Energy Corporation has recently established a business
relationship with ISNetworld to help our company objectively manage contractor requirements regarding environmental, health and safety programs. As a result of this action, contractors and their subcontractors who perform work at our locations including production sites and drilling sites, pipeline/compressor locations, shops, facilities and yards are required to subscribe to ISNetworld. Failure to subscribe to ISNetworld may result in having your approved vendor status revoked
."

ISN is an online service that coordinates & disseminates information about adhering to health & safety regs.

http://isnetworld.com/whatIsISNetworld.asp

"ISN collects self-reported conformance information from vendors, verifies its accuracy, and then reports the results in an easy-to-follow format. This allows corporations to select those resources that best meet internal and governmental requirements, ..."
is there a database that keeps track of oil/gas E&P mishaps?

RSS

© 2024   Created by Keith Mauck (Site Publisher).   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service