With gas @ $4.30 mcf, the Pine Island Field area appears to be north of the commercial limits of the Haynesville Shale as far as Caddo Parish is concerned. With the wells costing what they do, the scientific community has a lot of code to crack for that type of well to ever become commercial, even with higher gas price.
Exco, clearly improved the frac on the Sharp 1in 18/16 versus Chesapeake's Sharp 7 in 18/15. I think the sections in T19 & 20 are going to be a lot more challenging than T18.
I have heard that these wells north of shreveport are producing condensate, which has been causeing problems with the wells. It will be inerseting to see how much condensate is produced, and also what the decline rate in these wells looks like.
ALongview, typically condensate sells for the same price of crude oil which is currently above $50 per barrel at the market point. There are some costs associated wih moving the condensate to market such as trucking or pipeline transport costs but these should be fairly small for NWLa.
One of the primary factors impacting condensate yield (Bbl/MMcf) is the "richness" of the produced natural gas. Most of the Haynesville Shale production is very lean natural gas and yields little or no condensate.
Unfortunately, it is good as in better than nothing. It will produce royalty income for those in your section, but the well is marginal enough such that, without new technology of some sort, they probably won't be doing much more drilling in the area for the time being. I'm pretty sure Goodrich wasn't too pleased with the well.
Wild Wood, I would say for being Matador's first well in the section and the area of the play it is a good well. Others may disagree since it is not at the same level as some operator's in the heart of the play. Eventually there should be additional wells drilled in your section and those may have even higher rates.
Overall, I would say you have a basis to jump up and down in front of your husband since the well will be generating real money.