Bonus Offer in Barnett Shale, City of Ft. Worth (For Comparison Purposes)
| DATE: | 9/21/2010 | REFERENCE NO.: | L-15058 | LOG NAME: | 062040 BOTANIC GARDEN |
| CODE: | L | TYPE: | NON-CONSENT | PUBLIC HEARING: | NO |
| SUBJECT: | Approve the Acceptance of a Lease Agreement with XTO Energy Inc., in the Amount of $582,801.68 for Natural Gas Drilling Under 110.988 Acres of City-Owned Properties Known as Fort Worth Botanic Garden Located at 2000 University Drive (COUNCIL DISTRICT 7) |
||||
| RECOMMENDATION: | ||||||||||||
It is recommended that the City Council approve the acceptance of a lease agreement for natural gas drilling under 110.988 acres more or less of City-owned properties known as Fort Worth Botanic Garden to XTO Energy Inc., for a two-year primary term in the amount of |
||||||||||||
| DISCUSSION: | ||||||||||||
On September 22, 2009, (M&C L-14836), Fort Worth City Council authorized the conversion of Fort Worth Botanic Garden for subsurface A Request for Bid Proposals (RFP) for Fort Worth Botanic Garden was advertised for three consecutive weeks in the Fort Worth Star-Telegram, published on July 15, 2010, July 22, 2010 and July 29, 2010. The following sealed bid for the gas lease was received and opened on August 5, 2010.
|
Link to story and map:
http://www.fortworthgov.org/council_packet/mc_review.asp?ID=14135&a...
Tags: Barnett, Bonus, Botanic, Chesapeake, Garden, Lease, Offer, Shale, XTO
Views: 350
Replies to This Discussion
-
landownerPermalink Reply by Tex Calhoun on -
I just talked to a landman last night regarding my city lot in Fort Worth (1/3 of an acre) and the bonus rate Chesapeake is offering (initially) is $1000/acre with 25% interest for a 3-year lease. Now I can probably get them up to $1500/acre with negotiation, but it's not going to go much more above that.
A couple of things you need to consider regarding the posted offer for the Botanic Gardens tract:
1.) It is in the best interest of gas companies to be especially generous with cities regarding gas leases since cities like Fort Worth write the rulebook for urban drilling.
2.) This is a large piece of property and it is literally the garden spot of Fort Worth. It has the most potential to be an unpopular deal, so the money needs to be very good.
-
Oil & Gas ProPermalink Reply by Skip Peel - Mineral Consultant on -
Tex, we use bonuses paid on bid tracts in the state mineral auction as a negotiating tool on a regular basis here in LA. They must be location specific of course. And yes, for an urban area this is a good size contiguous tract and that does influence value. The fact that it is the Botanic Garden has no practical application in valuing minerals unless there is a qualifying drill site included in the tract.
-
landownerPermalink Reply by Tex Calhoun on -
"The fact that it is the Botanic Garden has no practical application in valuing minerals unless there is a qualifying drill site included in the tract."
Yes. However there is a vocal contingent of folks who might use this as a propaganda tool.
The other relevant bit of information is that they are going to be drilling fairly close to the Cultural District (world-class museums, etc.) to access this property, which will also irritate some folks. However I suspect that they may be able to access it from the Union Pacific switch yard, if there's enough room for a pad site and the tollway construction doesn't interfere with access.
-
Oil & Gas ProPermalink Reply by The_Baron on -
a sealed bid negotiation is going to be a different animal than sitting down across the table from a landman.
-
landownerPermalink Reply by king john on -
thats an interesting idea. i wonder if an individual, with a sizable tract, in a desirable location, could do the same thing? in terms of the sealed bid.
also, i have no doubt that a municipality would get a better bonus than an individual, simply because of its "back scratch'n " abilities.
kj
-
Oil & Gas ProPermalink Reply by Skip Peel - Mineral Consultant on -
Depends on the size of the tract and its location. 110 acres is a nice size tract but it is not big enough to be attractive to develop on its own for the major shale players. Unless a company is looking to be a minority Working Interest, they will only bid where they consider the chances are good that they will be the operator. The wild card in this scenario may be if one or the other bidder was interested in acquiring the lease in order to use it as trade bait to consolidate another area they were looking to drill. And tracts with qualifying well sites are worth huge bucks in dense urban areas. I doubt this tract has a well site as it would have brought a higher offer regardless of tract size.
-
landownerPermalink Reply by Tex Calhoun on -
"I doubt this tract has a well site as it would have brought a higher offer regardless of tract size."
You're absolutely right. If they permitted a pad site on the Botanic Gardens property, there would be an immediate recall election of the mayor and entire city council.
-
landownerPermalink Reply by DJG on -
I think the only public officials with enough "cajones" to try approve a pad site on the Botanic Gardens grounds would be that soon to be jailed mayor and his equally corrupt council members out in Bell, California.
-
landownerPermalink Reply by Tex Calhoun on -
For a bit of perspective, back in Fall 2008, bonus rates were running up to $25,000/acre in Fort Worth until gas prices plummeted.
-
Oil & Gas ProPermalink Reply by Skip Peel - Mineral Consultant on -
Tex, thanks for the feed back. We were watching the Barnett leasing in the Fall of 2008 very closely on GoHaynesvilleShale. As you can imagine it got a lot of people's attention. And it also generated some interesting discussions concerning urban drilling. Many of the original GHS members will recall those discussions.
-
landownerPermalink Reply by intrepid on -
Ah yes. I do recall those days. This amount seems low in comparison but, the times, they are changing.
Click Forum and scroll down past the last discussion and click the "Follow" button.
Top Content
Groups
-
Natchitoches Parish
409 members
-
ALTERNATE ENERGY TECHNOL…
6 members
-
Bienville Parish, LA
253 members
-
Unleased Mineral Owners
287 members
-
Red River Parish
307 members
© 2026 Created by Keith Mauck (Site Publisher).
Powered by
