Fifth Circuit delivers a blow to the Pugh Clause, refusing to apply it to Compulsory Pooling Units.

Fifth Circuit delivers a blow to the Pugh Clause, refusing to apply it to Compulsory Pooling Units.

11.20.26  liskow.com

https://www.liskow.com/insights/fifth-circuit-delivers-a-blow-to-th...

Lessees should take note when the United States Fifth Circuit interprets a mineral lease clause that has been in use for nearly a century. Its recent per curium decision in Triple C Minerals, L.L.C. v. XTO Energy, Inc. is likely to affect leasing and development across the Haynesville Shale. The lease at issue, the Collins Lease, contained a fairly standard Pugh Clause, which can cause a lease to terminate as to the acreage outside a unit unless that acreage is separately developed or otherwise maintained. The clause is a contractual exception to the general rule of indivisibility under Louisiana’s Mineral Code, under which operations on any part of the leased premises maintain the entire lease. Importantly, the Collins Lease Pugh Clause referred to a “pooled unit or units” without distinguishing between compulsory (state-ordered) units and voluntary units formed by the lessee.

The lessor, Triple C, demanded that XTO release acreage under the Collins Lease that it contended was no longer maintained. XTO responded that the entire lease remained in force because the Pugh Clause did not apply to compulsory units. The Fifth Circuit agreed with XTO and affirmed the district court, holding that an intent to make a Pugh Clause apply to compulsory units must be “clearly and unequivocally express[ed].” The court reached this result even though the Louisiana Supreme Court in Peironnet v. Matador Resources Co. read a nearly identical provision to cover both compulsory and voluntary units. Instead, The Fifth Circuit emphasized a “more specific” decision, a Western District decision from roughly 50 years ago holding that the specific Pugh Clause there did not apply to compulsory units. Although the Collins Lease Pugh Clause was worded more broadly than the clause in Bennett v. Sinclair Oil & Gas Co., the court concluded that a general reference to a “pooled unit” was not a clear and unequivocal reference to compulsory units, which meant Louisiana’s default rule of indivisibility was not contracted away. 

For lessees in Haynesville, Triple C provides meaningful leverage. Many standard Pugh Clauses refer only generally to “pooled” units and do not expressly and clearly reference compulsory units. Under the Fifth Circuit’s reasoning, such a clause likely will not divide the lease when the acreage is included in a compulsory unit, and production from that unit may maintain the entire lease. In that situation, a lessee may be able to resist a lessor’s demand to develop acreage outside the unit or release it back to the lessor. For existing leases, oil and gas companies will need to be wary when relying on lack of operations outside of a compulsory unit to terminate a portion of the lease since a mineral lease once thought to be affected by a Pugh Clause may be fully in effect. For drafting new leases, parties should ensure that a Pugh Clause affirmatively mentions compulsory units as standard language referencing “pooling units” may only mean voluntary units created by the lessee. 

For more information about Triple C and its implications for mineral leasing and Haynesville development, contact Liskow attorneys Jamie Rhymes and Andrew Hughes, and visit Liskow’s Energy – Transactional practice page. 

Triple C Minerals, L.L.C. v. X T O Energy, Inc., 25-30741, 2026 WL 2771811 (5th Cir. Sept. 17, 2

 

Views: 55

▶ Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

sounds like the owners got "out lawyered" by whatever firm was representing XTO (Exxon).

Could be.  My first reaction is this is a typical appellate court ruling by judges with zero background in Louisiana oil and gas law.  If there are any voluntary units in the Haynesville Shale, I do not recall them.  I think that 100% are compulsory units.  I have asked my O&G attorneys about the impact of this ruling.

I would agree that 100% of the Haynesville units ar compulsory.  A few years ago, a small Shreveport operator leased some of our land to drill a Paluxy oil well, and his plan depended on creating a voluntary unit for his well.  Lease was extended one time, and he gave up.  Wasn't clear if some of the nearby land owners objected to sharing royalty if the well was on their property.   This was my first ever conversation about a voluntary unit, or any kind of unit for an oil well.

IMO, the ruling is not about XTO having better lawyers or a compelling argument.  It is about appellate judges who owe their seat on the bench to the O&G industry that funded their campaigns.

Skip, this case immediately caught my attention.  Recently, a lease that included a Pugh Clause allowed me to execute another lease on unpooled acreage after the expiration of the primary term.  AI advises me - In Texas oil and gas law, voluntary units are formed by private agreement (such as a pooling clause in an oil and gas lease or a unit operating agreement), whereas compulsory (forced) pooling occurs by order of the Railroad Commission of Texas under the Mineral Interest Pooling Act (MIPA). Texas does not have a compulsory fieldwide unitization statute. [1, 2, 3, 4]The Mineral Interest Pooling Act (MIPA), codified in Chapter 102 of the Texas Natural Resources Code, authorizes the Texas Railroad Commission (RRC) to force-pool separately owned mineral interests into a drilling unit when voluntary agreement cannot be reached. Enacted in 1965, it is narrowly tailored and used less frequently than forced pooling statutes in many other oil- and gas-producing states. By disclaimer, this is not legal advice.

In Louisiana the few Voluntary Units (VUA) that I know of are old oil units that cover only 40 or 80 acres.  That was easier to get mineral owners to agree to join in a voluntary unit.  With Louisiana gas units being 640 acres, voluntary units become harder to get the required agreement from multiple mineral interests.  With Haynesville Shale units not only are the multiple mineral owners, there are often multiple lessees.  The industry likes compulsory units (forced pooling) as they are relatively easy to get state approval and it puts them in the driver's seat.  In this case it is "horizontal Pugh clauses" that are being impacted.  There are many leases with a horizontal Pugh that releases any acreage not in production at the expiration of the primary lease term.  They are common in leases from the mid 1970s until today.  Or maybe I should say yesterday based on this ruling.  We dealt with this issue early in the first couple of years of GoHaynesvilleShale.com.  Kassi's leasing group was the prime example.

RSS

📧 Want email updates on new discussions?
Click Forum and scroll down past the last discussion and click the "Follow" button.

© 2026   Created by Keith Mauck (Site Publisher).   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service